Is Adding a Second Layer of Shingles a Good Idea? Pros and Cons Unpacked thumbnail

Is Adding a Second Layer of Shingles a Good Idea? Pros and Cons Unpacked

Published Dec 13, 24
1 min read


While adding another layer of shingles might appear as an easy solution, is it really the best option for your roof? We’ll explore the advantages, disadvantages, building code concerns, and other alternatives.

Cost-Saving vs. Long-Term Risks

Advantages: Adding a second layer of shingles can save on labor costs and time by bypassing the tear-off process. It's a commonly chosen option for those seeking budget-friendly roofing solutions.

Disadvantages: While cost-effective upfront, layering shingles can lead to several problems over time, including:

  • The extra weight can strain your roof’s structure, potentially causing sagging or other damage.
  • Difficulty identifying and fixing underlying problems, like leaks or rotting wood.
  • The lifespan of the new shingles can be compromised by uneven installation and the heat retention from the old layer.

Things to Know About Building Codes When Layering Shingles

Building codes typically limit the number of roofing layers to two. Exceeding this limit could result in legal violations, insurance complications, and safety risks. Always verify local codes and seek expert advice.

Why Weathercraft Advises Against Multiple Layers

While adding a second layer might seem appealing, Weathercraft recommends avoiding this approach. Here’s why:

  • In-Depth Repair Process: Removing the old shingles allows us to identify and repair hidden structural issues, ensuring long-lasting results.
  • Superior Shingle Adhesion: A clean surface allows for proper adhesion of new shingles, ensuring their durability and performance.
  • Enhanced Aesthetics: Single-layer roofs provide a cleaner, more professional appearance, as the shingles lie flatter and look more aesthetically pleasing.

Alternatives for Budget-Conscious Homeowners

For those on a budget, here are several alternatives to adding another layer of shingles:

  • Address Specific Problems Rather Than Replacing the Entire Roof: Instead of redoing your entire roof, focus on repairing individual problem areas.
  • Consider Energy-Efficient Roofing: Opt for shingles designed to provide better insulation, reducing energy costs over time.
  • Flexible Financing Plans: If budget is a concern, Weathercraft offers flexible financing options to help manage roof replacement expenses.

Need guidance on your roofing options? Contact Weathercraft for expert advice and a free consultation.

Join the Conversation: Have you thought about adding another layer of shingles? Share your opinions in the comments below! #RoofingTips #HomeCare